Just finished reading Shakespeare's Trollop by Charlaine Harris. This is the fourth book in the Lily Bard series. Actually, this is a reread for me, but the last time that I had read this series was more than a couple years ago and my memories of it were a bit foggy.
One thing that I love about the protagonist, Lily Bard, is that she isn't a happy-go-lucky-but-having-a-rough-patch stereotypical character. Her ordeal (revealed in depth in the first book of the series, but summarized in this book) fundamentally changed her outlook on life. As told by her, she is a completely different person now than she was before.
Tied in with that, I also love that this character grows and changes through the series. In the first book, I couldn't imagine her being in a healthy relationship with a man, but now she is and it works. The romance of this book is light as compared to the others, but I enjoyed that. It helped this feel more like a telling of the events of Lily's life – that there were romantic bits happening at the same time as the larger story, but they are not the main focus – instead of a “true” romance novel.
That being said, this book's main storyline, the murder of the town trollop was not compelling to me on a character driven level. I really didn't care for the character who had died, and the connection that Lily felt to the victim felt more than a little contrived (not that there wouldn't have been a true connection, just that I don't think Ms Harris dealt with this aspect very well). But the mystery angle of this novel, the twists and turns as Lily investigates the murder in her own way are very compelling. I am truly in awe of Ms. Harris' ability to write a believable mystery with unobtrusive clues left along the way. This is one of few mysteries that I have read that I just could not guess the ending. All the clues are there from the beginning, but it takes a mastermind to be able to piece it together by the end. Even Lily didn't figure out the identity of the murderer, instead stumbling onto it during the course of her investigation (thereby making the book and her character much more believable in my mind).
On the negative side, the secondary characters don't have any kind of strong development in this book. Even though there were big events (including a wedding!), these seemed to be almost throwaway bits to the storyline, added only to help us feel that life in Shakespeare continues to move forward. Apart from one scene with Bobo, these events don't even seem to have much impact upon Lily.
The writing itself is typical of Ms. Harris – done well. No typos that I noticed. Her sentence structure is clean and her word choices are geared more towards a large audience. She is not overly descriptive, instead choosing to focus more on the action. There is still enough there to picture everything that happens, but don't expect florid passages about how the trees looked against the moonlight.
Overall, definitely a good read. Strong mystery storyline, light touch to the romantic storyline. The only drawback is the minimal character development of the secondary characters.
Recommendation: Definitely read if you like a good mystery. The short length makes it a great choice for a long plane ride or for an evening or two of snuggling on the couch.
Prerequisites: While it could conceivably stand alone, you miss too much of the development of the main character. There are three previous books to the series, here, here and here.